The figure shows a lamina in \(\text{XY}\)-plane. Two axes \(\text{z}\) and \(z'\) pass perpendicular to its plane. A force \(\vec{F}\) acts in the plane of the lamina at point P as shown. (The point \(\text{p}\) is closer to the \(z'\)-axis than the \(\text{z}\)-axis.)

   

(a) torque \(\vec{\tau}\) caused by \(\vec{F}\) about \(\text{z}\)-axis is along - \(\hat{k}\)
(b) torque \(\vec{\tau}'\) caused by \(\vec{F}\) about \(z'\)-axis is along - \(\hat{k}\)
(c) torque caused by \(\vec{F}\) about the \(\text{z}\)-axis is greater in magnitude than that about the z'-axis
(d) total torque is given by \(\vec{\tau}_{net}=\vec{\tau}+\vec{\tau}'\)


Choose the correct option:
1. (c, d)
2. (a, c)
3. (b, c)
4. (a, b)

Hint: \(\tau=\vec{r}\times \vec{F}\).


Step 1: Find the direction of the torque aabout the two axes.
Consider the adjacent diagram, where \(r>r'\).
Torque \(\vec{\tau}\) about \(\text{z}\)-axis = \(\vec{r}\times \vec{F}\) which is along \(\hat{k}\)
Torque \(\vec{\tau}\) about \(\text{z'}\)-axis = \(\vec{r'}\times \vec{F}\) which is along \(-\hat{k}\)


 

Step 2: Find the magnitude of the torque about the two axes.

(c) |τ|z=Fr= the magnitude of the torque about the z-axis where r is the perpendicular distance between F and z-axis.
Similarly, |τ|z=FrClearly, r>r|τ|z>|τ|z

(d) We are always calculating resultant torque about a common axis.

Hence, total torque τnetτ+τ, because τ and τ' are not about a common axis.